About 1789, Nathaniel Brown was born on the family farm on Maggoty Creek in Franklin County, Virginia, the youngest of at least seven children born to Robert and Lucy Brown of Virginia. Nathaniel's father Robert Brown died with a will probated in 1815 in Prince William County, Virginia (1815, Book K, Inventory p. 398). Robert Brown may have been a member of the Virginia Soldiers of 1776. Known children of Lucy and Robert Brown are Constance Brown Dyson, Mary Brown Thompson, Samuel Brown (married Martha Thompson), Sarah Brown Akers, Martha Patsy Brown Highley, Susannah Brown Highley, and Nathaniel Brown.
Nathaniel Brown served in War of 1812 and married Mary Artimissa McElvain on 27 Nov 1812, in Franklin County, Virginia. Mary Artimissa McElwain was born between 1791-1794 in Virginia, the daughter of Thomas McElwain (McElvain) Sr. and Frances Kelly Price of Rockingham County, Virginia. Mary's sister Nancy married John Vincent. Mary's sister Phoebe married Thomas Highley, 30 Dec 1810, in Franklin County, Virginia. The Brown family, along with other families, migrated from Franklin County in Virginia to Muhlenberg County, Kentucky in 1822.
Nathaniel and Mary McElwain Brown settled near Cypress Creek in Muhlenberg County, Kentucky, now part of the Cypress Creek State Nature Preserve. Nathaniel Brown was a farmer and teacher. He is listed in 1822 Muhlenberg County Tax List as well as in the 1830 and 1840 Federal Censuses for Muhlenberg County. In 1830, Nathaniel is listed among 6 males and 4 females. Nathaniel died on his farm on Cypress Creek in 1845 and Mary died after 1850 in Muhlenberg County.
Contributed by Sue Heflin Woolsey.
Updated April 18, 2025.